About Us

A Legacy of Faith and Freedom Since 1911

Mission Hills United Church of Christ (MHUCC) was founded in 1911 as part of the progressive tradition of the United Church of Christ, whose roots go back to the Pilgrims and their pursuit of religious freedom and self-governance. From the beginning, we’ve been a place of open inquiry, evolving faith, inclusive community, and a deep commitment to justice and spiritual growth.

We welcome all people—regardless of background, identity, or belief—to join us in worship and fellowship.

How Mission Hills Became Home

The Mission Hills neighborhood began shortly after the Civil War when sea captain Henry J. Johnston purchased six acres for just 25 cents an acre. His daughter built the area’s first home in 1887. Developer George Marston named the neighborhood “Mission Hills” at the turn of the century—then a quiet landscape of groves and farmland.

Recognizing the growing community’s need for a spiritual home, Marston and Judge Sloan—both members of First Congregational Church—partnered with Rev. Rigdon and Earl Barr of the Central Christian Church to launch a Sunday school. They held gatherings in Rev. Rigdon’s home on Ibis Street. In time, Marston purchased land at Fort Stockton and Jackdaw Streets, and a redwood chapel was built—a collaborative effort between the Congregational and Christian (Disciples of Christ) churches. This partnership foreshadowed the two denominations’ future formal union.

Founding the Church

Marston invited Rev. John Doane, a Congregational minister visiting from Colorado, to lead the new church. In 1911, Mission Hills Congregational Church was officially formed with 67 charter members. Rev. Doane’s musical background shaped the early church culture, establishing a renowned boys’ and men’s choir—a passion for music that still enriches our worship today.

Following his passing, Rev. Henry Roberts became pastor, leading the church through significant growth. The current sanctuary was constructed in 1921, replacing the original chapel. Additions followed over the decades, including a chapel and education wing in 1950 and a community preschool in the early 1970s.

Rooted in Community and Resilience

In 1918, like many churches nationwide, MHUCC closed for 10 Sundays during the Spanish Flu pandemic. Yet even then, our Women’s Auxiliary recorded that “one very jolly evening” was enjoyed when restrictions briefly lifted—a reminder of the joy and community that endure through hardship.

We continued building our presence in Mission Hills, including the creation of the Green Manor senior housing complex and continued renovations of the church campus to better serve our members and neighbors.

A Musical Heritage

Our church’s pipe organ, originally gifted by Mary Cowles and Mrs. John Doane in memory of their mother, was selected and dedicated by John Doane, a prominent organist at St. John the Divine in New York. Over the years, it has undergone several renovations, most notably in the 1980s, when contributions from members and generous donors like Gail Butterfield helped restore and enhance our sanctuary’s beauty and sound.

In 1990, the sanctuary’s clay panel artwork by artist Gerald Thiebolt was dedicated to the glory of God and in loving memory of Jack and Gail Butterfield, beloved members of the congregation.

Becoming Mission Hills UCC

On June 14, 1994, the congregation officially embraced its denominational identity, becoming Mission Hills United Church of Christ. In 2006, we deepened our commitment to inclusivity by declaring ourselves an Open and Affirming Congregation, affirming our welcome to LGBTQ+ individuals and families.

In 2011, we celebrated our centennial year—a joyful milestone in our long journey of love, worship, and service.